GitHub CEO: Exempt Open Source Developers from EU AI Act

GitHub CEO Advocates for Open Source Exemption in EU AI Act

GitHub CEO Thomas Dohmke has urged for open source developers to be exempt from the European Union's proposed Artificial Intelligence (AI) Act, emphasizing the critical role of open source in AI development and Europe's potential to lead in the field.

The EU's AI Act and its Implications

The Artificial Intelligence Act (AI Act), first proposed in April 2021, aims to regulate AI applications based on their perceived risks. The European Parliament is expected to vote on a draft version in the coming months, with potential adoption by the end of 2023. Critics argue that the Act could inadvertently harm the open source community by imposing legal liability on general-purpose AI systems (GPAI). This could disproportionately affect independent developers who lack the resources to navigate complex legal challenges, potentially hindering AI progress.

Why GitHub Cares About EU Regulations

Despite being a U.S.-based company owned by Microsoft, GitHub has a vested interest in the EU's AI regulations. With over 100 million users, GitHub's distributed nature relies on a global developer community. The company's concern stems from the potential impact on open source software, which forms the backbone of many AI systems. Furthermore, Europe's proactive stance on tech regulation, exemplified by GDPR, often sets global standards. What happens in Europe can significantly influence regulations worldwide.

The Intertwined Nature of Open Source and AI

Open source and AI are deeply interconnected, with collaboration and shared data being essential for AI development. The AI Act, while well-intentioned, could create a chilling effect on open source efforts. The core issue lies in the potential legal liability for general-purpose AI systems. Big tech firms, with their substantial legal resources, are better equipped to handle such regulations, while independent open source developers, often volunteers, may struggle with compliance burdens.

Microsoft and GitHub's Stake in Open Source AI

Microsoft and GitHub stand to benefit from a thriving open source ecosystem, as seen with their Copilot tool, which assists developers using AI trained on open source code. However, this also places them in a precarious position, as they, along with OpenAI, face a class-action lawsuit related to AI copyright and training data. The widespread adoption of AI phenomena like ChatGPT underscores the need for robust regulation, as highlighted by EU Internal Market Commissioner Thierry Breton.

The Need for Balanced Regulation

Breton emphasized the dual nature of AI, offering both opportunities and risks, necessitating a solid regulatory framework for trustworthy AI. Dohmke echoed this sentiment, stating that the AI Act is crucial for European technological leadership and economic growth. He stressed the importance of fairness and balance for the open source community.

Dohmke's Plea for Exemption

Dohmke argued that open source developers are individuals, not entities, and the compliance burden should fall on companies shipping products. He pointed out that many open source contributors are volunteers, hobbyists, or academics who do not profit from their work and lack dedicated compliance departments. Exempting them would ensure that the benefits of AI align with European values and fundamental rights.

Key Takeaways:

GitHub CEO Thomas Dohmke advocates for exempting open source developers from the EU AI Act.
Open source is fundamental to AI development, and the Act could stifle innovation.
The EU AI Act aims to regulate AI based on risk but may create legal liabilities for general-purpose AI systems.
Independent developers may struggle with compliance, while large companies are better equipped.
Europe's regulatory approach can set global standards.
Microsoft and GitHub have a vested interest in a healthy open source ecosystem.
Balanced regulation is crucial for fostering trustworthy AI and European leadership.

Event Promotion:

TechCrunch is hosting the TechCrunch All Stage event on July 15, 2025, in Boston, MA. The event focuses on strategies, workshops, and connections for founders and VCs at all stages. Early bird registration offers significant savings.