Generative AI's Intellectual Property Problems and Risk Mitigation Strategies
Generative AI Has an Intellectual Property Problem
by Gil Appel, Juliana Neelbauer, David A Schweidel
Publication Date: April 07, 2023
Product #: H07K15
Related Topics: AI and machine learning, Technology and analytics, Risk management, Creativity, Intellectual property
Understanding Generative AI and its Challenges
Generative AI, a technology that leverages data lakes and question snippets to identify patterns and relationships, is increasingly being adopted across various industries, particularly in creative fields. However, its rapid proliferation has brought to light significant legal and ethical challenges, primarily concerning intellectual property (IP).
Key Intellectual Property Concerns with Generative AI
Copyright Infringement
One of the most pressing issues is the potential for copyright infringement. Generative AI models are trained on vast datasets, which often include copyrighted material. When these models generate new content, there's a risk that the output may be substantially similar to existing copyrighted works, leading to legal disputes.
Ownership of AI-Generated Works
The question of who owns the intellectual property rights to content created by AI is complex. Current IP laws are largely designed around human authorship. Determining whether an AI itself can be an author, or if the ownership lies with the AI's developer, user, or the owner of the training data, is a subject of ongoing debate and legal interpretation.
Unlicensed Content in Training Data
Many generative AI models are trained on data scraped from the internet without explicit permission from the copyright holders. This raises concerns about the legality of the training process itself and the subsequent use of AI-generated content derived from such data.
The Legal Landscape and Ongoing Cases
Courts are actively grappling with how to apply existing intellectual property laws to the novel challenges posed by generative AI. Several high-profile cases have already been filed, seeking to clarify these legal ambiguities. These cases are crucial in setting precedents for how AI-generated content will be treated under copyright, patent, and trademark law.
Mitigating Risks for Companies Using Generative AI
Companies that utilize generative AI must proactively address these IP risks to avoid legal repercussions and maintain ethical standards. Key strategies include:
Ensuring Compliance with the Law
It is imperative for businesses to stay informed about the evolving legal framework surrounding AI and IP. This involves understanding current regulations and anticipating future changes.
Mitigating Potential Risks
- Data Due Diligence: Companies should rigorously vet their training data to ensure it is free from unlicensed content. This may involve using curated datasets or obtaining necessary licenses.
- Provenance Tracking: Developing robust methods to demonstrate the origin and creation process of AI-generated content is crucial. This can help in establishing ownership and defending against infringement claims.
- Clear Usage Policies: Implementing clear internal policies for the use of generative AI tools and the handling of AI-generated content can help manage risks and ensure responsible deployment.
Product Information
- Item: #H07K15
- Publication Date: April 07, 2023
- Price: $11.95 (USD)
Available Formats:
- Audio MP3
- Audio M4A
- Audio CDROM
- Audio Cassette
- Bundle
- DVD
- Event Live Conference
- Event Virtual Conference
- Word Document
- Electronic Book
- ePub
- Financial
- Ebook
- Hardcover/Hardcopy
- Hardcover/Hardcopy (Color)
- Hardcover/Hardcopy (B&W)
- Web Based HTML
- Kit
- License
- Magazine
- Mobi
- Multimedia CDROM
- Multimedia Windows Media
- Paperback Book
- Powerpoint
- Paperback/Softbound
- Paperback/Softbound (Color)
- Paperback/Softbound (B&W)
- Registration Fee
- Short Run
- Subscription
- Service
- Video CDROM
- Video DVD
- Video Flash
- Video VHS (NTSC)
- Video VHS (PAL)
- Video Real Player
- Microsoft Excel Spreadsheet
- XML
- Zip File
Available Languages:
- English
- Spanish
- Chinese
- Danish
- French
- German
- Japanese
- Portuguese
- Polish
- Russian
- Slovak
- Traditional Chinese
Copyright Permissions
Copyrighted PDFs are for individual use only. To obtain copyright permission to share this PDF with your team, purchase one copy per user.
Order for your team and save!
- # of Copies | Price
- 1-4 | List Price
- 5-10 | $9.75
- 11-49 | $9.50
- 50-499 | $9.25
- 500+ | $9.00
Related Products
- CGIP: Managing Consumer Generated Intellectual Property by Pierre R. Berthon, Leyland Pitt, Jan H. Kietzmann, Ian McCarthy
- Has Generative AI Peaked? by Oguz A Acar
- Intellectual Property Strategy by Andy Wu, Aticus Peterson
Footer Information
HBR Store Sections:
- Promotions
- Popular Topics
- Collections
- Books
- Tools
- Articles
- Case Studies
- Magazine Issues
- Search by Topic
HBR Series:
- HBR Work Smart Series
- HBR 10 Must Read Series
- HBR 20-Minute Manager Series
- HBR Emotional Intelligence Series
- HBR Guide Series
- HBR Insights Series
- HBR Women at Work Series
- HBR Working Parents Series
My Account:
- My Library
- Orders
- Account Settings
- Email Preferences
- Sign In
Contact Us:
- U.S. Canada: 800.988.0886
- International: 617.783.7500
- Email: customerservice@harvardbusiness.org
- Help Center
- Returns Policy
- HBR Press
Legal Information:
- Privacy Policy
- Copyright Information
Affiliates:
- Higher Education
- Corporate Learning
- Harvard Business Review
- Harvard Business School
Copyright © 2025 Harvard Business School Publishing. All rights reserved. Harvard Business Publishing is an affiliate of Harvard Business School.
Original article available at: https://store.hbr.org/product/generative-ai-has-an-intellectual-property-problem/H07K15